Every leadership team believes it has a strategy. Far fewer can prove it holds up once you start asking questions about it. Here are three we ask early on in strategy work, not to catch anyone out, but because the answers are usually more revealing than the strategy document itself.
First, if you asked your whole leadership team to define the strategy in one sentence, would you get the same answer twice? This sounds like a simple test, but it is a genuinely useful one. A strategy that only lives clearly in one person’s head, however capable that person is, is not yet a strategy the business can execute consistently. Most leadership teams can answer this one confidently. The real value is in checking whether confident and consistent are actually the same thing across the room.
Second, how would you know if this quarter was genuinely better than last quarter, not just busier? Activity and performance get confused constantly. A team can be working harder, closing more deals, moving more volume, and still be worse off than the quarter before, if margins slipped or costs crept up quietly in the background. Fewer leaders can answer this one with real confidence, because it needs business-level metrics tracked consistently over time, not just a sense that things feel busy.
Third, how do you know if you are ahead of, or behind, similar businesses in your market? This is the one almost nobody can answer with real data behind it. Most businesses can describe their own performance in isolation. Very few can say with any confidence whether that performance is actually good, because good only means anything relative to what similar businesses are achieving.
None of this means a business is doing badly. It means these three questions sit at different levels, and most reporting only ever answers the first one well. The strategy exists. Whether it is working, and how it compares, are separate questions entirely.
Which of these three would you find hardest to answer honestly right now? It is usually the most useful place to start.
